All-Stars is a continuation of play for players who played in the recreational division of AYSO in the fall (EXTRA players are not eligible). All-Star play starts at the 8U level and continues through 14U. The All-Star season follows the fall season, with play taking place in January and February. Players for the All-Star teams are chosen by the All-Star Committee to participate in All-Stars based upon their performance in games during the recreational season and an All-Star tryout process. The All-Star Committee shall be comprised of 4-8 selected coaches and board members who have coached in the respective division during the fall season or are qualified based on their experience.

All-Star play is highly competitive, and is often a stepping stone for those who wish to take part in the EXTRA program. A full commitment to all All-Star games, tournaments, and practices is required to be considered for selection to the All-Star team